Skip to main content

We Know How It Ends

The Woman in Red by Diana Giovinazzo | Hachette Book Group

 "Experience the epic life story of Anita Garibaldi, a courageous, headstrong revolutionary who fought for freedom and self-determination in nineteenth-century Brazil, Uruguay and Italy."

I love historical fiction, when it is done well. I won't waste my time or yours by making you read a whole post to discover that I did not like The Woman in Red by Diana Giovinazzo. It was a 1/5 star read for me, and I struggled to get into it. I will go as in depth an explanation as I can without spoiling the novel, because I would never say "do not read this book," but if you want to know why, please read on (there are no spoilers).

The Why

Everything about the story was set to please; a strong female historical figure, fighting for her own freedom as well as standing by her husband's side during many revolutions, but the execution was disappointing. The narrative wasn't as strong as I had hoped. While Anita was clearly a strong-willed person from her early childhood, I felt that Giovinazzo was somehow disconnected from the narrative despite the fact that the story is written in first person. To write historical fiction (or any story for that matter), you need to connect to your characters so that the plot flows nicely and so your readers can connect to the characters and the time. This novel felt mechanical, and it was hard to connect with Anita because of it.

The Danger of Stereotypes

Stories set in North and South America cannot escape their colonial history, and with a story like Anita's, you would expect that at one time or another, she met or saw someone who was indigenous to Brazil. However, to write in an indigenous character "just because" and to revert to dangerous stereotypes can be a form of erasure. This was another aspect of this novel that completely turned me off. Yes, the story was set in the 1840's, so I understand that for the sake of accuracy, Anita would refer to indigenous Brazilians as "Indians," but the backstory to the character Ruthie was dangerously stereotypical and glazed over the violent history the indigenous peoples of that area would have encountered during Portuguese colonization.

Anita Garibaldi seems like an amazing historical figure, and I would like to learn more about her, but I think this novel could have been better. The trouble with most historical fiction is that people will know how the stories end (if they are acquainted with the history). If the story feels disjointed and stereotypical, many people who are drawn to this kind of story will likely not want to turn the page. 

I am grateful to Read Forever Pub and Grand Central Publishing for sending me this novel, but it just didn't sit right with me. On to the next adventure! If you would like to request a review, or have a recommendation for me, please comment below, email me (theopinionatedbookworm@gmail.com) or follow me on Instagram (@theopinionatedbookworm1).

Comments

  1. PhoebeAugust 25, 2020 at 6:24 AM

    That colonial history part just seems tone deaf to me. Honestly I wouldn't mind a little anachronism in historical fiction when it recreates some modern sensibilities that we find so integral to being human just for the sake of connecting with the character and the story.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The House of the Spirits

A good friend of mine once told me, "if a book has a rating of 4 or more stars on Goodreads, it is probably a safe bet that you will like it." This is why I almost always choose my books by their Goodreads rating, a strategy I am currently rethinking after reading The House of the Spirits by Isabel Allende. With an average rating of 4.23/5 on Goodreads, I thought I was going to love this book, and for the first four chapters, I did. However, as the story progressed I started to struggle, which has led me to believe that when choosing books I might need to employ tactics that do not solely rely on Goodreads ratings. The Patriarch Isabel Allende's novel takes place in early to mid twentieth century Chile, and tells the story of landowner Esteban Trueba, a man who went from rags to riches using nothing but his mother's honourable last name. Esteban is a classic example of an upperclass patriarch; he believed that by going back to the land of his mother's fami...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Will. The Words. The Way.

I started 2020 by reading The Ten Thousand Doors of January  by Alix E. Harrow, and although this past year has been hard for so many, for me, it was also one of adventure. I was accepted to my dream university, but prohibited from pursuing that particular adventure by events that we are all well aware of. I briefly lost my job, but became closer with my coworkers because of it. And I was hurt deeply by someone I trusted, but eventually moved on. I cannot say that Harrow's magical words from her debut novel were the reason behind all of these adventures, but I must admit that I was inspired by January to become more resilient, so I find it fitting that I start 2021 with Harrow's second novel, The Once and Future Witches.  The Once and Future Witches Juniper, Agnes and Bella are three sisters that were separated, but somehow found each other again in the city of New Salem, a place where women who rally for the right to vote are accused of witching. "But witching is nothing ...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Kings and Queens of Old

For as long as I can remember, I have had a deep, nearly obsessive, fascination with the past. The stories I was drawn to were ones of kings and queens, knights and wizards, myths and legends. Regardless of the truth behind these stories, the language and the heroic characters that populated the tales created a romantic attachment that lasts to this day.  Even now, I prefer stories of fantasy and adventure to those of real life, and in admitting this I feel like I have failed in my duty as a bookworm, as I only just finished reading The Lost Queen by Signe Pike, even though it was published in 2018.   The Lost Queen I have to sincerely thank Netgalley and Atria Books for giving me access to this ebook, because it was truly a wonderful adventure. The story begins when Languoreth, daughter of a King who still follows the Old Ways of their ancestors, is a child who just lost her mother and must learn to navigate womanhood in a changing world. As the years pass, Languoreth ex...
Post a Comment
Read more